Determining the class of a solo

    
Determining the class of a solo    19:34 on Saturday, September 16, 2006          

hexedecimal99
(7 points)
Posted by hexedecimal99

I've been practicing Concertino, Op. 107 by Cecile Chaminade. I am planning on playing it for a contest and I cant find out what class it is (AA, A, B?) could someone please help me out?


Re: Determining the class of a solo    20:09 on Saturday, September 16, 2006          

Account Closed
(3248 points)
Posted by Account Closed

In my smart music it is listed as a B.

<Added>

Sorry, I meant a D.



<Added>

According to my sources it a level D in the ABRSM or first year freshman in college.


Re: Determining the class of a solo    20:27 on Saturday, September 16, 2006          

hexedecimal99
(7 points)
Posted by hexedecimal99

wow you reeeeally scared me for a minute, i didnt think to check smart music, and i live in ohio so AA is the hardest and D is the easiest lol

<Added>

(its an A here)


Re: Determining the class of a solo    20:31 on Saturday, September 16, 2006          

StephenK
(395 points)
Posted by StephenK

It is a grade 3 piece on flute world.
http://www.fluteworld.com/Merchant/grading.htm

It is severely overdone and would not be a good choice unless you can nail it musically as well as technically. It is the musical expression that will sell the piece. You may be the 10th person to play it in front of the judges that day.

Get recordings of it, Susan Milan and Ransom Wilson have wonderful recordings of it. I also have Paula Robison and Willian Kincaid's version, and although I don't like their reditions (and I do LOVE Paula Robison's playing in general) it wouldn't hurt to listen to any rendition that is available.


Re: Determining the class of a solo    08:53 on Sunday, September 17, 2006          

Patrick
(1743 points)
Posted by Patrick

I might disagree with that a bit, if you can make an overdone piece fresh sounding, it is really an accomplishment. The problem with a piece like the Chaminade is that it is so easy to imitate the expression one hears on any given recording.

If you can truly make that piece your own, hats off to you, I would be impressed


Re: Determining the class of a solo    13:22 on Sunday, September 17, 2006          

hexedecimal99
(7 points)
Posted by hexedecimal99

Thanks for the replies, so far my favorite recording is by james galway.


   




This forum: Older: Piccolo types?
 Newer: pearl piccolo age