Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.

    
Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    11:10 on Thursday, October 11, 2007          

viiolina
(4 points)
Posted by viiolina

Hi, please look at the photo and tell me if this violin has a crack (or about to crack) mark on the back or not. The person selling said there are no cracks but I want your input...it's kind of hard to see at first but I see 2 lines in the wood....please help me.

http://www.imagehosting.com/show.php/1243347_DSCF0996.jpg.html


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    23:42 on Friday, October 12, 2007          

viiolina
(4 points)
Posted by viiolina

why is no one commenting??? IS this forum a joke? geez, I really need some help here...


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    00:46 on Saturday, October 13, 2007          

arabians207
(259 points)
Posted by arabians207

I don't really know how to tell.. but personally if your worried I probably would not buy it. Wood varies a lot.. and also does have some imperfections that aren't always negative. Since the lines are symmetric im guessing its part of the wood.. but don't go buy what i say :P

Try to take it to someone (other than the seller, because they more than likely wont say anything bad about it) like a teacher that can help you pick out a violin. Make sure you try many of them (i probably tried at least 7-8 and took them to my teacher before i bought one)

Good luck!


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    15:47 on Friday, October 19, 2007          

leighthesim
(471 points)
Posted by leighthesim

it looks like the grain in the wood to me but i wouldn't chance it


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    14:11 on Sunday, October 21, 2007          

jcwjcw79
(3 points)
Posted by jcwjcw79

If it is in the center of the back, then what you are seeing is a seam where two pieces of wood are glued together to form the back of the violin.


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    16:57 on Sunday, October 21, 2007          

blackhellebore89
(156 points)

The seller may just be saying that. take it to a music shop or your teacher for a second opinion. i do know some one who has a cracked violin and it doesn't sound overly bad at all but it would be best to ask. remember it never does hurt to..


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    20:09 on Sunday, October 21, 2007          

viiolina
(4 points)
Posted by viiolina

thanks but it was an ebay auction and I didn't bid. It turned out to just be the grain of the wood.


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    05:16 on Wednesday, October 31, 2007          

elidatrading
(68 points)
Posted by elidatrading

Those aren't cracks.


Re: Please help me...determine if this violin is growing a crack or not.    20:16 on Sunday, November 11, 2007          

celticfiddlefrea
k

if it is on the seam, you can tell easily. take your index finger and lightly tap all around the edge of the top and bottom face of the violin. Your taps will sound VASTLY different from the others if there is a crack.


   




This forum: Older: Stradivarius Copy made by "Lignatone" - logo is a lion
 Newer: Nice article about violin strings