kurt cobain sucks.

How about the person that runs this forum - tally up all the inputs so we can see what the results are.

Personally Neil Pert wins hands down. Even though Led Zepplin is my favorite band of all time, what did John Bonham ever do that was better? I want to hear that track.

vocals- bono
bassist-victor wooten
guitar-steve vai or joe satriani
drummer- neal peart
corey

Wooo steve vai!! but no billy sheehan? you must know billy sheehan as one of the greatest bassists ever cos he plays with vai!

Guitar: Stevie Ray Vaughn
Drums: John Bonham
Bass: Les Claypool
Vocalist: Robert Plant

what about the best piano/organ player?
I think Elton John is pretty good

Vocals: Freddie Mercury
Guitar: Hendrix, Clapton, Cobain, Page
Bass; Flea, McCartney
Drums: Neil Pearth,John Bonham, Phil Collins

I forgot best writer Bob Dylan

id personally have to say my band would be
Vocals: Layne Staley
Guitar: Jimi Hendrix
Bass: Flea
Drums: Bonham

Layne is extremly overlooked with the problems he had with heroin. He was probaly one of the most unique and emotion singers in the past 4 decades.

the rest is obvious, though debatable by many

VOCALS: Gregg Allman or John Lennon
GUITAR: Duane Allman or Stevie Ray Vaughan
BASS: Jack Bruce
DRUMS: Ginger Baker

Vocals: Jaymz Hetfield, Cannibal Corpse guy
Guitar: { Kirk Hammett | Dave }, Joe Satriani, Slayer guy, SOAD guy
Bass: { Rob Trujillo | Jason | Cliff }
Drums: Lars Ulrich, Joey Jordinson

Vocalist: Freddie Mercury

Guitarists: Jimmy Page, Angus Young, Brian May

Bassists: Geddy Lee, John Deacon

Drummers: Roger Taylor, Neil Peart


...Note how Queen made it into every category. XD.

Vocals- Freddie Mercury

Guitar- Jimmy Page, Nuno Bettencourt

Bass- Jaco Pastorius

Drums- John Bonham

Singer: Guy Garvey from the band Elbow (UK) (better then Freddie Mercury)

Guitar: Jan Akkerman from the band Focus (NL) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jan_Akkerman

Bass: Greg Richling from The Wallflowers (US)

Drummer: - from the band Godspeed You! Black Emperor (CAN)

Then you have a nice international band aswell

I think these are the best

Guitarist- Slash (Guns N'Roses) Kirk Hammet (Metallica)

Singer- Axl Rose (Guns N' Roses) or good old freddy Mercury (Queen)

Bassist- that guy from red hot chilli peppers :S

Drummer- gotta be Lars Ulrich (Metallica)

Vocals-Andrew Strong

Guitar-Slash or Clapton

Bass-Victor Wooten or Flea

Drums-Ginger Baker