Who is better? John Williams HAS written good stuff, and his music is nice to listen too, but he steals some ideas from other composers, listen real hard, you`ll know what I mean.
James Horner has done some good stuff as well, also nice to listen too. Who do you think is better?

john williams is deffinitally better

Oh please, not this argument! If you`re going to use the plagerism argument you should look straight at Horner. He`s not the worst composer, quite the contrary. But when compared to John Williams anythign is inferior. Every Williams fan knows he SELF-Plagerises, but every composer does. He has composed more sequel scores than anyone (and he also holds the most amount of Oscar nominations in the world) so this could be why. Or not.

In short, Williams beats Horner hands down.

Williams lol what ever he is now where near better then horner,William is a old dryed up pice of S*IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Case Study: Williams vs. Horner

James Horner has composed one, four-note Evil motive. He has used it in almost every single one of his scores to date. He hasn`t even tweaked the pitch at ALL.

John Williams has produced similar themes or music, but not once has he ever made a blatant copy that is note-for-note. Adn before you say "Quidditch, Year Two", that was actually tracked straight from AotC, so technically is not a rip-off.

So, we`ve been provided with evidence. And Williams comes out on top. And always will.

Supper and star war`s are the same opneing just on a different note so stop talking bull