offset vs. inline G
offset vs. inline G
19:30 on Thursday, February 15, 2007
|
|
|
Re: offset vs. inline G
19:36 on Thursday, February 15, 2007
|
|
|
Flutist06 (1545 points)
|
Actually, it's quite the opposite. Most student flutes have offset, and many intermediate/pro flutes (especially older ones) have inline G. On recently built flutes, you'll find the offset readily available throughout the range of instruments. There original reason for pro flutes being in line is that one of the most respected makers at the end of the 19th/early 20th centuries by the name of Louis Lot started building flutes with Inline G's, which eliminated a rod and got more instruments out the door for a greater profit. Since heis flutes were some of the most popular instruments of the day, other makers copied that particular feature, and we ended up with a split between pro flutes and student flutes. Today, with the relatively recent revelation of carpal tunnel and repetitive stress injuries, the Offset G is making a comeback in a big way, as it is more ergonomic for most (but not all) players. There's no reason to choose one over the other besides comfort. Neither will affect intonation or tone. I personally prefer an offset, but I played an inline for about 3 years before I got my Tom Green, and had no problems with that configuration.
|
|
|
|
Re: offset vs. inline G
19:35 on Friday, February 16, 2007
|
|
|
Tibbiecow (480 points)
|
It sounds like you had a great time, Toni. I'm glad you ended up playing instead of staying home sick.
My flute has an inline G; it works for me since I have a long ring finger. I would say that I prefer the flute that plays better...an inline G can be plugged, or even have a key extension put on it if your hand conformation is suited to an offset G.
It is important to remember that things like a B-foot, open holes, engraved lipplates and such are noticeable manifestations of an 'advanced' flute. What you can't see just by looking is the engineering of the tonehole placement and mechanism, and the headjoint's cut and taper, which will have MUCH more dramatic influence on the flute's quality. As many eBay frequenters have noticed, you can buy a brand new Piece-O'Junque flute for $150 or so- complete with solid silver headjoint, pointed key arms, B-foot, splitE, and open holes. And if you do, you'll find out that you just bought yourself a $150 lamp, light bulb/lampshade not included!
Two in our community band have handmade Haynes flutes, with closed holes, C-foot and offset G. These look just like your average student flute, but they sure don't sound like a student flute!
|
|
|
|
Re: offset vs. inline G
21:05 on Friday, February 16, 2007
|
|
|
|
|
|