Vocals-i personally have narrowed it down to Axl Rose and Sebastian Bach.......wich is awesome cuase they frequently do tracks together.....but any way.

Guitar-i think it would be close......randy rhoads(RIP).....or Van halen.....both greats

Bass-Don't Know many bassists.....but i think Micheal Anthony

Drums-TOMMY LEE
Does ne body else have an oppinion

If you put Rhoads and Van Halen on the list, you've got to add Ozzy Osbourne and David Lee Roth to your vocals. I'm a big GNR fan, but Roth and Ozzy definately have a better voice than Axl Rose.

ur right......what about mike tramp from white lion.......not really what you'd call metal.....but has a good voice

Yeah, he's got a good voice, but he fits more in the hair metal genre. Still, a good voice!