shires vs edwards......

    
shires vs edwards......    13:10 on Monday, December 24, 2007          

n0tshort
(36 points)
Posted by n0tshort

so it is that time again, a new horn and im thinking about getting in the shires or edwards class, Im looking for somthing a little jazzy small bore .500 ish but I want a slightly bigger bell 7.75 or 8 in bell.

I spent over 2 hours playing a shires .525 1glw7.75 and loved it the next day i jumped on an edwards t302 excalibur for a few hours and loved it to.

If you have experience with this class of horn and have a recomendation id love to hear it. while all opinions are apreciated, Id especially like to here from professionals and semi pro players that have 15+ years of experiance.
thanks

me (the guy without spell check)


Re: shires vs edwards......    02:16 on Tuesday, December 25, 2007          

puffycheeks
(25 points)
Posted by puffycheeks

From my experience... both are great horns. If you want one that looks really pretty, get a Shires. If you want a horn that doesn't care about looks, only about performance; get an Edwards. Edwards tech team is amazing. Though I have two really close buddies who play exclusively jazz and they have gone through the entire process of choosing a new jazz horn and taken King and Yamaha...


Re: shires vs edwards......    08:36 on Wednesday, December 26, 2007          

bobsacamano
(158 points)
Posted by bobsacamano

Both horns are beautiful in terms of looks and performance. One is not "better" than the other. It's just a matter of personal preference.


Re: shires vs edwards......    11:51 on Wednesday, December 26, 2007          

n0tshort
(36 points)
Posted by n0tshort

ok, well in that case im going back to the shop again and playing them again (which i would have done any way) and since there in the same class, i guess ill just figure out which one i like better.


   




This forum: Older: Anyone ever heard/played this solo?
 Newer: Trombone Excerpts