Is it worth getting this Violin restored?

    
Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    12:34 on Monday, December 29, 2003          
(kickinpretty)
Posted by Archived posts

Hi, i have just brought a violin which is "The Maidstone" By John G.Murdoch & Co Ltd London EC. for £70.00 UK pounds. It is pre-war but i dont know an exact date.

It is missing the bridge and has some scratches to the front and back.

Somebody has attempted to re-varnish the outer areas of the violin but it was very badly done, the strings need replacing as well.

1. Is it worth spending the money to get it re-varnished by a restorer?

2. Will the missing bridge affect the value?

3. What valuation could i expect to get for a fully restored "maidstone"?






Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    16:00 on Monday, December 29, 2003          
(Sean)
Posted by Archived posts

1. Is it worth spending the money to get it re-varnished by a restorer?
-Yes, or you could try doing it yourself, it`s really not that hard. You just have to find wood varnish. You could save lots and lots of money.

2. Will the missing bridge affect the value?
-No, the bridge doesn`t matter that much.

3. What valuation could i expect to get for a fully restored "maidstone"?
-Not sure, so the name of which you said is in the violin?



Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    16:01 on Monday, December 29, 2003          
(Sean)
Posted by Archived posts

2. Will the missing bridge affect the value?
-No, the bridge doesn`t matter that much.


-Even though without the bridge and strings, the violin is WORTHLESS.


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    16:10 on Monday, December 29, 2003          
(kickinpretty)
Posted by Archived posts

Thanks for the replies, whilst i coulsd re-varnish myself, i feel it would be better done by a restorer as i dont want to have an adverse affect on the value.

As for the name inside its as i posted before, would this have any connection to "Murdoch & Murdoch" or is it a completely different company?

I purchased the Maidstone for the purpose of learning to play along side my six year old daughter, i wanted something old and with a mature sound and also something that will hold its value, hopefully i have picked a decent violin - Your thoughts on this though would be most appreciated


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    19:36 on Tuesday, December 30, 2003          
(Liz Ward)
Posted by Archived posts

maidstones are a turn of the (19th-20th) century trade violin originating from germany. there are lots of them and by today`ds standards they`re not bad. Price for a fully restored one varies: we have never managed to get more than £200 on ebay and that took some doing and was for a bow and case as well. A specialist shop might get £300 or so for the violin. you won`t make any profit on it if you resell it, i`d suggest you just enjoy learning on it once it`s set up properly (expect to pay £100 or so)

Liz


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    14:54 on Wednesday, December 31, 2003          
(Sean)
Posted by Archived posts

Liz Ward,

Yes, but by the time (kickinpretty`s) 6-year-old daughter has a 6-year-old daughter of her own or granddaughter it would be worth a lot more. That`s because others just like it have been thrown away or damaged badly.


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    14:56 on Wednesday, December 31, 2003          
(Sean)
Posted by Archived posts

celloprof@hotmail.com is my working email the other one never worked.


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    14:58 on Wednesday, December 31, 2003          
(Sean)
Posted by Archived posts

.


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    19:22 on Wednesday, January 7, 2004          
(doopee)
Posted by Archived posts

i have a violin thats a 100 years old at least. if you refinish it it won`t have the best sound and it costs a lot just get a knew violin.


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    06:57 on Sunday, June 13, 2004          
(Tina)
Posted by Archived posts

We have a French Medio Fino that needs refinished and put back together. I am not sure of the value and will refinishing it damage the sound?


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    17:29 on Sunday, June 13, 2004          
(Liz Ward)
Posted by Archived posts

Medio Finos are French trade violins, very cheaply made. Certainly not worth revarnishing. They don`t sound too bad though.

Liz


Re: Is it worth getting this Violin restored?    04:39 on Friday, June 10, 2005          
(oriel)
Posted by Archived posts

I have one with the same label for which I paid £250. I doubt you would get your money back unless you did the work yourself. They seem to go typically for about £200. Good luck!


   




This forum: Older: Help
 Newer: Nice article about violin strings