Is This Harmonic Possible?

    
Is This Harmonic Possible?    22:31 on Thursday, April 2, 2009          

Ultra_Legend
(7 points)
Posted by Ultra_Legend

I'm playing a Scherzo by Daniel van Goens (Op. 12, No.2). It says I should play a G (space above the top line in Treble Cleff) as a harmonic (has a 0 on top of it). I have not been able to find it. Is it an actual harmonic or do I have to shift from my previous note (G second from bottom line in Treble Cleff as a harmonic) all the way up there?


Re: Is This Harmonic Possible?    20:44 on Sunday, April 5, 2009          

bobmrbassman
(59 points)
Posted by bobmrbassman

It is at the end of the finger board on the A string,


Re: Is This Harmonic Possible?    23:11 on Sunday, April 5, 2009          

Ultra_Legend
(7 points)
Posted by Ultra_Legend

Is there any other one closer to my previous note?


Re: Is This Harmonic Possible?    22:23 on Friday, April 10, 2009          

bobmrbassman
(59 points)
Posted by bobmrbassman

I'm sorry but that harmonic turned out to be too high and a little flat. I found another one that was right on the G string but I'm afraid it was down in almost the same place but on the G string.


Re: Is This Harmonic Possible?    20:40 on Saturday, April 11, 2009          

Ultra_Legend
(7 points)
Posted by Ultra_Legend

Thanks for the help. I think that the music had a mistake and that it really was not supposed to be a harmonic.


Re: Is This Harmonic Possible?    01:42 on Friday, May 8, 2009          

Scotch
(660 points)
Posted by Scotch

As a natural harmonic, that pitch is impossible to play on either the A or D string. It's the eighth natural harmonic on the G string and the twelfth natural harmonic on the C string.

You can play it as an artificial harmonic on the D string by stopping the first G with your left-hand thumb and simultaneously lightly touching your left-hand ring finger on the node a perfect fourth higher.


Re: Is This Harmonic Possible?    00:09 on Friday, May 15, 2009          

Ultra_Legend
(7 points)
Posted by Ultra_Legend

Thanks for the reply, I may try that. But I might just play it normally, thats how I've been practicing it.


   




This forum: Older: What are the names of the strings on a cello?
 Newer: Wolf Tones