Horn vs. Mellophone

    
Horn vs. Mellophone    19:08 on Tuesday, December 5, 2006          

shrinkingclarine
t1991

If I wanted to play french horn, but switch to mellophone for marching band, would it be hard? What are the differences embrochure/playing wise? Also vice versa-mellophone to french horn. Thanks.


Re: Horn vs. Mellophone    22:53 on Tuesday, December 5, 2006          

flutes-4ever
(183 points)
Posted by flutes-4ever

I'm 90% sure that changing from a mellophine to french horn and vise versa,is not a change at all.A guy that plays mellophone 4 marching band and french horn 4 concert band said there is not much difference between a baritone,mellophone,and french horn.So ur all good 2 go!!!I 'm already done with marching band.Kinda i'm happy about it,but now I have nothing to do in the morning's and nothing to do friday nights


Re: Horn vs. Mellophone    12:56 on Wednesday, December 6, 2006          

ekdavies
(208 points)
Posted by ekdavies

There are some significant differences. Apart from beginners, most french horn players use a double horn (F & Bb) with 4 or 5 valves whereas "standard" mellophones have 3 valves. They can be pitched in Eb, F, G or Bb however, even the F mellophones are an octave higher than a french horn and the Eb mellophones are the same pitch as a Eb tenor horn.

To use a standard french horn mouthpiece you would need an adaptor because the bore is normally larger on a mellophone. In principle, you can develop an embouchure which can be used on most brass instruments but most teachers encourage students to specialise.


Re: Horn vs. Mellophone    16:08 on Friday, December 8, 2006          

laeta_puella
(344 points)
Posted by laeta_puella

Mellophones use trumpet fingerings, which are allegedly the same as baritone fingerings. But french horns use... gasp... french horn fingerings, so you'll end up needing to learn a new set for each. also there's the fact that you opperate the valves with the opposite hand.


Re: Horn vs. Mellophone    00:01 on Saturday, December 9, 2006          

flutes-4ever
(183 points)
Posted by flutes-4ever

>_> same difference........>_<


   




This forum: Older: Good Times Being a Band Geek
 Newer: trying to find the right horn for me