The old days: I played either Conn or Holton school-owned instruments in high school. Held first or second chair, could run the full normal range of the instrument with good tone and pitch. Would get positive comments from judges in state competetions. Used a Holton MDC mouthpiece which worked well.

Fast forward 30 years I haven't touched a horn since (accomplished keyboard player though). I would like to get a horn to play duets with my wife on piano. I expect to take some lessons and would hope to sound presentable in 2-3 years.

I know of a private owner that has two nice H177 horns for sale in the $1800 range. Wondering what others might think of this choice for me?

If the price is okay with you the H177 is probably the perfect horn for a come-back player. I am playing one now while waiting for my classic Hoyer Geyer-wrap (valve rebuild) and my Reynolds Kruspe-wrap to get back from the repair shops. The H177 slot easily and have a smaller bell than say a big Conn or Holton. My first horn was a H177 which I played from Jr. High into college. The characteristics of the H177 make it a great horn for a comeback, because it doesn't play as big as a Conn 8d,Holton 179, or my reynolds contempora.